A quick look at the Shenzhen “peace declaration”

So a peace declaration has to be a good thing, right? Especially when the leaders of the three great powers issue it at a first-of-its-kind summit.

The declaration issued by Presidents Putin, Trump and Xi after their trilateral summit at Shenzhen consists of four substantive paragraphs following a standard introductory paragraph about them having had an in-depth discussion.

The four key paragraphs are, in turn, clichéd, dangerous, tricky and the repetition of an important commitment.

1. As permanent members of the United Nations Security Council, China, Russia, and the United States committed to reform the U.N. so that the U.N. can respond more effectively to global challenges and conform to its fundamental mission of international peace and security.

If they had said what reform they are committed to, it would have been less of a cliché and more of a, you know, statement. Or declaration. There have been decades of intensive debate about UN reform and screeds of reports and proposals. So far, so little progress. This sentence does not visibly move the needle of that discussion.

2. The three countries plan to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations. They reaffirmed the importance of stable energy flows.

Perfectly timed as the climate summit, COP 31, nears its end in Antalya, Türkiye, here comes a commitment to produce more fossil fuels and thus keep average global temperatures rising. This kind of irresponsibility is no longer surprising – yet it still takes the breath away.

Putin needs this to beat sanctions and fund Russia’s aggression against Ukraine.Trump wants it since slowing supply and rising prices because of his badly thought out war on Iran are part of what explains the US mid-term elections and the losses he and his party suffered.

It could be that Trump thinks Putin will help set up a deal between Iran and the US to get ships moving through the Strait of Hormuz at something like the pre-war rate. But Iran has its own strategic and economic calculus, which may not match either their adversary’s or their ally’s.

3. The three heads of state recognized that the principle of state consent and respect for immunities of State officials are of paramount importance, and concurred that the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.

On the one hand, this is Trump and Putin taking aim at the ICC, which they each have reasons to dislike – Putin because it issued a warrant to arrest him, and Trump because it issued a warrant to arrest Israel’s Netanyahu.

On the other hand, when they say, “respect for immunities of State officials”, they don’t say much. They don’t say “impunity” for example. And state officials do indeed have diplomatically agreed immunities, well defined by international agreement. Read that way, the statement is vacuous.

Likewise their statement that, “the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.” With sentiments like this, it’s worth applying the principle of the hypothetical contrary: would anyone agree with the contrary statement that the ICC and other bodies must abuse their jurisdiction? No? In that case the statement that they must not is pointless.

So that’s the tricky paragraph: read one way, it’s three great powers taking aim against international law; read the other way, it’s a pile of nothing.

4. The three heads of state reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. The three countries will conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.

This is a worthwhile reaffirmation of the longer statement that these three governments together with France and the UK issued in January 2022, when they also agreed to avoid arms racing and dangerous international behaviour. The dialogue on reducing nuclear risks has been going for over a decade and it is good that these three leaders support it. And, of course, the treaty commitment to preventing nuclear weapons proliferation is 56 years old.

A worthwhile paragraph, in short, but nothing new.

At least it wasn’t Yalta redux

Before the summit, there was a lot of excited discussion about whether the meeting would be a new Yalta: like when Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin met and carved up Europe, would today’s big three carve out their global spheres of influence? It made for some fun reading but was never very likely.

It is, all scepticism and sarcasm to one side, and despite the boost for the fossil fuel industry, a positive that three leaders who still have much that divides them – places and issues where their interests diverge or clash – can sit down together, say some nice things, and issue a bland statement for peace. It has not achieved anything but that’s considerably less bad than it could have been if they had got as far as even talking about spheres of influence in their closing statement.

After the summit, those aspects of world affairs that are worrying remain so. Those sources of hope in people and some governments beginning to address those problems remain hopeful. And on we go, not distracted by Shenzhen.